Right Wrongs Nobody

I was interviewing veteran Georgian diplomat, Tedo Japaridze, at a fashionable Tbilisi cafe when a woman walked up to him and said, “I’ve seen you. You’re with Ivanishvili. When are you going to put those criminals behind bars?!” She was referring to members of the United National Movement that many people feel should be punished for whatever crimes they were supposed to have committed, now that they have lost power in the government. Tedo, who is now Chair of the Committee for Foreign Affairs for the Georgian Dream party, patiently listened then replied, “It’s for the courts to decide.”

Bidzina Ivanishvili’s billion dollar party has its work cut out. The people that voted for the Georgian Dream have high expectations and if Ivanishvili doesn’t deliver quick enough, he’ll have hell to pay. Throwing scapegoats to the masses is a quick fix that won’t go down so well with those who have taken him to his word to not go on a political retribution spree.

Molly Corso wrote an excellent story about this in Eurasianet. My Moscow Times piece about this is below.

(Justice by Ivo Salinger 1920)

Georgia’s Democracy Needs More Fair Trials

Former Georgian Prime Minister Nino Burjanadze has appeared from her lair to call on the incoming parliament to release those “political prisoners” authorities arrested in May, when she launched a ridiculous attempt to force President Mikheil Saakashvili from power. Burjanadze says prosecutors, judges and false witnesses should be punished, but she doesn’t get it. We’re supposed to be living in a different Georgia today. People must be tried first.

At least this is what Bidzina Ivanishvili, whose opposition coalition won the parliamentary elections on Oct. 1, promised when he pledged to bring democracy to Georgia.

Burjanadze was part of the team that established a state-controlled judicial system that collected money from defendants in plea-bargain arrangements. This basically turned into a policy of legalized extortion. People paid money to the state to avoid trial. At first, it was OK because the ruling party targeted people everybody accepted were corrupt. But when the system became institutionalized as a draconian zero-tolerance policy, it soon touched virtually every Georgian in the country. Such a system cannot be dismantled overnight.

Many members of Ivanishvili’s electorate are angry, like Burjanadze. They have their personal tallies of wrongs and expect to see the same kind of revenge the ruling party dished out on crooks in 2004 applied to them now. But Ivanishvili can’t do this.

Everybody is closely watching whether he’ll repeat the pattern of political retribution and renege on his word to refrain from a policy of revenge. He has, however, said controversial cases of Saakashvili’s government would be tried and the guilty punished. That was enough to send Justice Minister Zurab Adeishvili packing. Deputy Defense Minister David Akhalaia and his brother, Interior Minister Bacho Akhalaia, are also missing in action, while Defense Minister Dmitry Shahskin is on an extended vacation in the U.S. Saakashvili has even issued a decree that government officials can use their diplomatic passports for one year if they are fired.

Ivanishvili is in a precarious situation. There are many people who think that democratic elections got Ivanishvili into power, so he should be their preferred autocrat. But these people are impatient and could turn against Ivanishvili just as quickly as they turned against Saakashvili. Ivanishvili hasn’t yet clearly explained that the just society that Georgians demand means everybody is entitled to a fair trial and the democracy-in-the-making means he must work with some people his supporters would like to see imprisoned.


2 thoughts on “Right Wrongs Nobody

  1. Thanks Paul, a good piece, as always. I do think that a Truth Commission would serve Georgia much better: what went wrong would come out, and be talked about. Going into another round of locking people up would not serve anyone.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s